Holes in eminent historian, Irfan Habib’s arguments - Ayodhya RAM Temple Issue!

There are several holes in eminent historian, Irfan Habib’s arguments as shown below:


1. Irfan Habib, eminent historian, has pointed out that the Archaeological Survey of India [ASI] did not mention that lime-surkhi used in the five levels of structure could not have been part of an earlier Hindu temple because such mortar came with the Muslims. BUT THIS ARGUMENT IS WRONG: THE USE OF LIME-MURKHI DOES NOT NECESSARILY MEAN IT WAS A MUSLIM PLACE. HINDUS HAVE LIBERALLY USED ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURAL STYLES. EVEN IN MY OWN ANCESTRAL VILLAGE-HOUSE, WE HAVE TWO MEHRAABs [DOWNWARD CONCAVE-CURVING TWO CURVES STARTING FROM THE TOP MIDDLE DARWAAZAA TILL THEIR POINT OF RESTING ON THE TWO SIDE-SUPPORTING PILLARS] resting on two pillars in the middle of the front big spacious entrance-hall which essentially is an architectural style that had come along with Islamic invaders in India….THIS DOES NOT MEAN THAT MY ANCESTRAL HOUSE WAS BUILT BY BABUR……...I HAVE SEEN AS CHILD MY ELDERS HAVING GOT THIS MEHRAAB ARCHITECTURAL-STYLE INCLUDED WHILE OUR ANCESTRAL HOUSE WAS BEING REBUILT…………………….! IRFAN HABIB’S ARGUMENT IS LIKE SAYING THAT ALL THE AMMUNITION BEING MANUFACTURED IN THE WORLD INCLUDING THE USA IS BEING MADE IN CHINA, SINCE CHINESE HAD INVENTED THE GUN-POWDER…………………!

2. Irfan Habib says WRONGLY that the ASI jumped to the conclusion that a mysterious chamber beneath the squarish block of calcrete protruding from the fifth level was of “some place of importance”. Irfan Habib DOES NOT UNDERSTAND THE IMPORTANCE OF AND DOES NOT SEEM TO HAVE VISITED PLACES OF WORSHIP USED BY THE INDIAN HINDU MYSTICS/SAADHUs. I HAD VISITED AMARKANTAKA, the source of the holy river NARMADA , in the year 2003. There, I was told of the existence of an underground chamber in the premises of the particular MATHHA area by a BENGALI SAADHU who had used it earlier for doing QUIET/PEACEFUL SAADHANAA [MEDITATION], UNDISTURBED AND FREE FROM DANGER OF ATTACKS BY FOREST ANIMALS………………! THE GARBHA-GRHA housing the SHEVA LENGA in the famous SHEVA temple in Nasik is located in the underground chamber…………………………! THUS, IT IS FULLY CLEAR THAT THE UNDERGROUND CHAMBERS ALWAYS HAVE BEEN OF FULL IMPORTANCE IN THE HINDU SPIRITUAL SCHEME OF THINGS!



Aade Shankaraachaarya, the great Indian seer, had done FULLY HONESTLY his duty of uniting the DIVIDED Indians of his time SUPERBLY……….!


NOW, the AYODHYA VERDICT has given a GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY to the RSS to try and UNITE the DIVIDED Indians of today…………….!


NO, SORRY FOR MY BLUNT and UNPALATABLE YET TOTALLY TRUTHFULLY TRUE TRUTHFUL COMMENT: – THE Bharatiya Janata Party [DESPITE ITS OWN CURRENT IMAGE-CORRECTION attempts] DOES NOT SEEM TO BE CAPABLE OF PLAYING THIS IMPORTANT ROLE, since the majority of the Indians don’t have much faith in the BJP anymore - ONLY THE RSS CAN PLAY THIS ROLE EFFECTIVELY AS THE ‘MODERN-DAY AADE SHANKARAACHAARYA’ THAT THE MAJORITY OF THE CURRENT INDIANS YEARN FOR TODAY, ONLY IF THE RSS CHOSE TO SHOULDER THIS VITAL HISTORICAL RESPONSIBILITY THAT HAS BEEN THRUST UPON IT BY THE CURRENT AYODHYA VEDICT…………………!


The AYODHYA VERDICT HAS GIVEN US A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY TO EVOLVE AN ALTOGETHER NEW POWERFUL NATIONAL IDENTITY BASED ON ‘THE INTEGRATED NATIONALISM’ CUTTING ACROSS ALL THE RELIGIOUS/SECTARIAN DIVIDES………………………..!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

DID KABIRA/KABIRA-PANTHA GURUUS ORIGINATE THE AUM-SOHAM MANTRA?

WHY IS DONALD TRUMP BETTER THAN HILLARY CLINTON AS NEXT USA PRESIDENT?